Eisenkot’s ‘Perversion of Parliamentary Democracy’

Jack GUEZ / AFP via Getty Images, Kassandra Verbout/Trumpet

Eisenkot’s ‘Perversion of Parliamentary Democracy’

The Israeli Knesset voted Tuesday to replace Knesset Speaker Amir Ohana with Matan Kahana of Gadi Eisenkot’s Yashar party, a move designed to consolidate Eisenkot’s authority as Israel’s next prime minister—even though it isn’t certain he will become prime minister.

  • The speaker of the Knesset is the legislature’s presiding officer. He sets the body’s legislative agenda and maintains discipline and order. It is not a symbolic office.
  • Yashar won the second-highest number of seats in the Knesset at 21, behind Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s Likud’s 27.
  • But with the help of Yashar’s coalition partners, as well as anti-Zionist Arab parties holding 19 seats, Kahana received 66 votes to 52 for Ofir Katz, the candidate from Netanyahu’s party.

Eisenkot has regularly and publicly ruled out creating a coalition with the Arab parties because of their hostility to Israel as a Jewish state. Yet he relied on them to get Kahana elected and put him in a position to become the next prime minister.

  • Meanwhile, Netanyahu remains prime minister of a caretaker government and will likely get the next chance at forming a permanent government should Eisenkot fail.

Jerusalem News Syndicate summarized what Eisenkot’s bloc is aiming for: “the political benefits of a governing majority without the responsibility—or political consequences—of forming one.” This is leading to “the prospect of a caretaker government pursuing one agenda while an opposition-controlled legislature pursues another.”

This scenario isn’t unprecedented, but it is highly unusual and a betrayal of the principles Eisenkot ran on during the election.

  • Jerusalem News Syndicate accurately called the Kahana election “a perversion of parliamentary democracy.”

Before the election, Israel was already suffering serious societal crises. The election results and Eisenkot’s subsequent power plays are further adding stress to a society on the brink of collapse.