Can ASEAN Save the Philippines From China?

The U.S. is not winning against China, and Beijing is flexing its muscle, leaving the Philippines with few strategic options.
 

Manila, philippines—The Philippines is hosting the 49th asean Summit in Manila from November 15 to 18, with United States President Donald Trump in attendance. However, the distance between the U.S. and the Philippines has become political, not just geographic. Can asean help the Philippines fend off China?

asean formed in 1967 and is made up of 11 member nations—Brunei, Cambodia, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia, Myanmar, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand, Timor-Leste and Vietnam. The group also has 12 dialogue partners, including China, the U.S., Japan, South Korea, India, Russia and the European Union. The organization is intended to provide a platform for major powers to engage with Southeast Asia on economic, political and security issues. Despite the involvement of these powerful nations, asean has provided fewer and fewer avenues for the Philippines to counter Chinese aggression in the South China Sea.

A Narrowing Path for the Philippines

The Philippines has set the theme for this year’s summit as “Navigating Our Future, Together.” But behind Manila’s show of unity, the future appears to be unraveling. When it is finally stitched back together, China, not the U.S. or even asean, may be the common thread.

The current system has failed to resolve the most pressing issue asean has tried to address: Beijing’s territorial claims in the South China Sea. To pass a resolution, a consensus must be obtained among the 11 member-states. asean members Cambodia, Laos and Myanmar, historically in China’s orbit, have prevented asean from taking action on the issue. Also Malaysia, Indonesia, Brunei and others have preferred to deal with China bilaterally, preventing the Philippines and Vietnam from achieving a consensus in asean forums, leaving asean in an institutional paralysis in dealing with the South China Sea issue.

There is no clearer demonstration of asean’s failure to address this issue than the 2012 Scarborough Shoal incident that left China with effective control over the area. Cambodia has repeatedly blocked efforts by the Philippines and Vietnam to include maritime disputes with China on the asean agenda. In July 2012, for the first time in the bloc’s then 45-year history, it was unable to release a joint resolution on issues involving the Southeast Asian region. The South China Sea issue is increasingly shaping asean’s relevance and future as a multilateral bloc that purportedly seeks to maintain regional security in the Indo-Pacific. Because it is structurally in limbo, asean cannot deal with China in the South China Sea. The Philippines must look for other options.

A year later, the Philippines pursued other options in defending its maritime rights. In 2013, the Philippines brought China to court in an arbitral tribunal under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, seeking a ruling based on international law regarding China’s contentious nine-dash claim. In 2016, the court overwhelmingly ruled in favor of the Philippines, invalidating China’s claims. China disregarded the decision and continued its aggressive behavior. Since the international court has no law enforcement arm, who will enforce the ruling?

The U.S. Is Losing the Philippines

Although the Philippines has a defense treaty with the United States, it has reservations about Washington’s defense commitments, having seen its lack of resolve to end the wars in Ukraine and Iran and the Trump administration’s general policy of leaving American allies to fend for themselves. During the 2012 Scarborough Shoal incident, America dithered and failed to prevent China from fully controlling Philippine waters.

Washington also failed to lobby the Duterte administration to support its strategic interests in the Philippines. Although the Philippines saw a revitalized alliance with the U.S. recently, President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. has sought to diversify Philippine defense networks to reduce reliance on the U.S. Manila has strengthened military cooperation with Japan and India, signed a visiting forces agreement with France, and is expanding its defense arrangements with Australia. These developments demonstrate that the Philippines is increasingly looking beyond its traditional American alliance to secure its interests.

Many Philippine defense analysts and policymakers warn that if a conflict breaks out over Taiwan, the Philippines could find itself trapped in a war between the U.S. and China and used as a staging ground for U.S. forces—a scenario that is widely unpopular with Filipinos.

Trump’s arrival in Manila to attend the summit is seen as a ploy to repair relations with Southeast Asian partners that have been neglected under his America First policy and the trade wars he has waged on China and America’s traditional allies. Trump may have arrived in Manila to win back trust, but the message from the Philippines is clear: The days of exclusive American reliance are over; Manila is exploring other security options.

China Is Leading the Philippines Toward War

Whatever path the Philippines takes, it has no choice but to engage with China. China’s goal is to achieve complete control over the South China Sea. This goal runs counter to Manila’s vital interests. So far, neither country will back down, and war appears almost inevitable. If conflict breaks out, America will likely leave the Philippines to fend for itself.

In “China Is Steering the World Toward War,” Trumpet editor in chief Gerald Flurry wrote:

The Spratly Islands are claimed by the Philippines, Malaysia, Taiwan and Vietnam. China is ignoring these nations’ territorial claims. China is being aggressive and provocative.

These militarized islands now function as forward bases for Beijing to challenge seven decades of American naval dominance in the Pacific Rim. This should alarm the world! …

China is intimidating the nations of Southeast Asia into submission to its will. It is forcing these countries to do what it wants.

Everything is headed in the direction of war.

Mr. Flurry has warned for years that China will gain complete control of the South China Sea as U.S. influence in the region deteriorates as a result of curses caused by disobedience to God. In Leviticus 26, God outlines the blessings ancient Israel and its descendants would receive if they obeyed God, as well as the curses that would befall them if they disobeyed. One of these curses is that God would break the pride of Israel’s power (verse 19). America is one of the modern-day nations descended from ancient Israel (for proof, read Mr. Armstrong’s free book The United States and Britain in Prophecy). America’s wartime history after World War ii shows that God has indeed broken the pride of America’s power. The once great superpower that many nations, such as the Philippines, revered has lost the will to defend its allies from enemy nations such as China. This is why the strong bond between the Philippines and the U.S. is certain to break.

asean will not save the Philippines from Chinese encroachment. Bible prophecy indicates that as America recedes from the scene, China will step in to control strategic choke points, including the South China Sea. Ezekiel 38 foretells the rise of a massive Asian power bloc led primarily by Russia (anciently known as Gog) and secondarily by China (Magog). The book of Revelation refers to this superpower alliance as “the kings of the east” (Revelation 16:12) and reveals it will field a gargantuan army of 200 million soldiers (Revelation 9:16). Ultimately, asean member states—alongside asean dialogue partners like Japan, India and South Korea—could be absorbed into this bloc, contributing their vast populations to this unprecedented military force.

To better understand the prophetic significance behind the developments within the Southeast Asian region, read Mr. Flurry’s article “China Is Steering the World Toward War.”