Trump, Putin and the Lesson of Yalta
Good morning,
Yesterday, the first-ever three-way meeting between the leaders of America, Russia and China ended with a “peace declaration” that never mentioned Ukraine. And as Vladimir Putin sat down with Donald Trump, Russia was launching strikes across Ukraine.
[BRIEF]
- President Trump’s assessment of the meeting: “I think a lot of wonderful things can come out of this—or at least start.”
- Poland’s foreign minister, Radosław Sikorski, gave the better verdict: “[I]t is difficult to judge—by their fruits we shall know them—but the optics of this hugging Putin, calling him a friend, causes us some concern.”
- Poland well knows what happens when an American president trusts a Russian dictator.
Putin said, “Our three states are the victors in World War ii, and we hold joint responsibility for maintaining international peace and security.” That history is definitely worth considering.
- The Soviet Union began World War ii as Hitler’s partner. In September 1939, it invaded Poland from the east while Germany invaded from the west.
- And the China that sat among the Allies was not Xi’s People’s Republic, which was founded in 1949. It was Chiang Kai-shek’s Republic of China, whose nationalist armies bore the brunt of the war against Japan, and which survives today in Taiwan.
- Putin is rewriting history to claim that these three powers have the right to run the world. And Trump is going along with it.
Many are comparing Shenzhen to Yalta, the famous trilateral meeting in February 1945 of the U.S., Britain and Russia. The comparison is instructive.
- Roosevelt, Churchill and Stalin met in Crimea to decide the shape of the postwar world, including what would become of Poland and the rest of Eastern Europe.
- Roosevelt had written Churchill in 1942, “I think I can personally handle Stalin better than either your Foreign Office or my State Department.” Regarding dealing with Stalin at Yalta he said, “I think that if I give him everything I possibly can and ask nothing from him in return, noblesse oblige, he won’t try to annex anything and will work with me for a world of democracy and peace.” Roosevelt’s pride deceived him.
- Stalin promised free elections in Poland; they never came. Yalta effectively put an American signature on Stalin’s occupation of Warsaw. Barely a year later, Churchill was warning about the “Iron Curtain.” The Soviets kept Eastern Europe imprisoned behind it for more than four decades.
In 2015, candidate Trump said, “I think I would just get along very well with Vladimir Putin.” Trumpet publisher Gerald Flurry responded with the same quote Poland’s foreign minister used, writing:
Jesus Christ said, “By their fruits you shall know them.” President Trump doesn’t appear to agree with the Bible here. And he will live to regret it! He is dangerously naive about Putin.
You see that dangerous naivety in Trump’s coziness with China as well. But it is especially egregious with Putin, a man Mr. Flurry identifies as the “prince of Rosh” in Ezekiel 38, the leader of a coming Russian-Chinese military bloc. He wrote that Putin “has a long pattern of diabolical evil on the level of Joseph Stalin.”
Yesterday, President Trump stood between that prince and his Chinese partner very comfortably. Mr. Flurry warns that as we draw closer to Putin, “We get further and further away from God!”
Will Burnham Pull Britain Back Into the EU?
Britain must reset its relations with the European Union, Prime Minister Andy Burnham said on November 16 as he expressed hope that Britain would rejoin the bloc in his lifetime:
The Brexit we were given has not worked. We have lost more than we gained.
A reset summit in Brussels is scheduled for tomorrow, where Burnham and EU leaders will meet and produce a joint statement that is expected to include commitments for:
- Britain to follow the EU’s rules in food and agriculture
- Britain to allow EU students subsidized access to British universities
- More power for the European Court of Justice to resolve disputes
- Britain to pay more money to Brussels
In the longer term, Burnham wants to bring Britain within the EU’s customs union. This would end Britain’s ability to sign trade deals with independent nations in exchange for better access to the EU’s market. For Remainers, this would be a crucial step on the road back to EU membership.
But does Europe want Britain back? Europe’s decades-long transformation into a superstate was always unpopular among and resisted by the British. The last thing EU leaders want is the return of one of its most divisive large members.
- One EU diplomat told the Guardian they were getting fed up with endless renegotiations: “Clarity is what we need more than anything from the UK. Don’t come back until you know what you want. Work out what your options really are and then come to negotiate.”
- What EU leaders really want is for Britain to submit to Europe’s rules, while remaining outside.
Rejoining the EU is not the solution, but the support for it reflects Britain’s inability to solve its own problems after Brexit. Our August 2016 Trumpet issue, published just weeks after the vote, stated:
Is this a new birth of freedom for Britain? At the Trumpet, we have certainly pointed to the flaws in Britain’s relationship with Europe. We have lamented the loss of sovereignty to Europe. So is it sunlit uplands from now on? Sadly, no. While the EU has certainly caused problems for Britain, the biggest wounds are self-inflicted and won’t go away even when this divorce is finalized.
Now Andy Burnham wants to try to solve those problems by surrendering to Germany and Europe. The Bible prophesied this impulse. Hosea 5:13 states:
When Ephraim [prophetic term for Britain] saw his sickness, and Judah saw his wound, then went Ephraim to Assyria [modern-day Germany], and sent to king Jareb: yet could he not heal you, nor cure you of your wound.
Ephraim sees how infirm it has become. But seeking healing from Europe will prove to be yet another curse.
Eisenkot’s ‘Perversion of Parliamentary Democracy’
The Israeli Knesset voted Tuesday to replace Knesset Speaker Amir Ohana with Matan Kahana of Gadi Eisenkot’s Yashar party, a move designed to consolidate Eisenkot’s authority as Israel’s next prime minister—even though it isn’t certain he will become prime minister.
- The speaker of the Knesset is the legislature’s presiding officer. He sets the body’s legislative agenda and maintains discipline and order. It is not a symbolic office.
- Yashar won the second-highest number of seats in the Knesset at 21, behind Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s Likud’s 27.
- But with the help of Yashar’s coalition partners, as well as anti-Zionist Arab parties holding 19 seats, Kahana received 66 votes to 52 for Ofir Katz, the candidate from Netanyahu’s party.
Eisenkot has regularly and publicly ruled out creating a coalition with the Arab parties because of their hostility to Israel as a Jewish state. Yet he relied on them to get Kahana elected and put him in a position to become the next prime minister.
- Meanwhile, Netanyahu remains prime minister of a caretaker government and will likely get the next chance at forming a permanent government should Eisenkot fail.
Jerusalem News Syndicate summarized what Eisenkot’s bloc is aiming for: “the political benefits of a governing majority without the responsibility—or political consequences—of forming one.” This is leading to “the prospect of a caretaker government pursuing one agenda while an opposition-controlled legislature pursues another.”
This scenario isn’t unprecedented, but it is highly unusual and a betrayal of the principles Eisenkot ran on during the election.
- Jerusalem News Syndicate accurately called the Kahana election “a perversion of parliamentary democracy.”
Before the election, Israel was already suffering serious societal crises. The election results and Eisenkot’s subsequent power plays are further adding stress to a society on the brink of collapse.
IN OTHER NEWS
War for Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal continues: Eight of 15 judges from Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal, backed by Prime Minister Donald Tusk, voted on Tuesday to remove the immunity of Bogdan Święczkowski, the court’s chief justice, from prosecution. This follows a request from Attorney General and Justice Minister Waldemar Jurek and is part of a broader fight for control of the court between the pro-European Union Tusk and the more populist and nationalist president, Karol Nawrocki. Ultimately, the faction that controls the court controls Poland.
India buys nearly 500 million barrels of Russian oil in 2026: Russia supplied India with approximately 483 million barrels of oil during the first nine months of 2026, according to data reported by Interfax yesterday. This growing energy relationship is part of a much broader strategic partnership that has expanded significantly since Western nations imposed sanctions on Russia for its invasion of Ukraine. Bilateral trade reached a record $59.9 billion in fiscal year 2025–26. The two nations are also deepening joint research, development and production of advanced military technology and increasing cooperation along Russia’s Northern Sea Route, with a pilot voyage planned for 2027. As these economic, maritime and military ties strengthen, the groundwork is being laid for India to join a biblically prophesied, Russia-led Asian military alliance.